Review Surface — CLIPFORGE

RENDERS — 3

Artifacts for this claim come from docs/state, preserved from the handoff session. Re-render to produce fresh ones.

lernquadrat · migration-relaunch·felix·9x16DRAFT WATERMARK BURNED IN

CONTACT SHEET — THE REVIEW SURFACE

DER SCROLL-STOPP-TEST

92/ 100SHIP

THRESHOLD 85/100 · SET BY REVIEW.MD

Hook & thumbnail truth23/25

Craft & polish17/20

Motion quality13/15

Capture cleanliness15/15

Brand compliance15/15

Narrative clarity, muted9/10

AUTO-FAIL CHECKS — 6

PASSconsent banner: none (old site's banner killed during static capture; new site bar killed by v4.1 hygiene)
PASSWayback toolbar: absent (if_ replay variant + CSS kill)
PASSbroken image regions: none in the filmed scroll span (integrity gate rejected two half-styled snapshots first)
PASSsafe areas at camera 1.0: clean; chips inside safe area
PASSmax 2 lines / em dash / audience end card / evidence / watermark / ≤15s / linter-first / AI imagery / zoom budget: all ok
PASSduration 13.4s ≤ 15s

DEFECTS BY LOOP — DISPLAY ONLY

LOOP 189

[F0] Vorher: TYPO3 chip animated in from zero → invisible at exactly frame 0, poster lost the context completing 'TYPO3 raus.' → §7 poster-first rule governs: frame-0 elements do not animate in; chip got posterStatic (fix in Typography.tsx + Migration.tsx)
[pipeline] first loop-2 render silently shipped the OLD Typography code — webpack filesystem cache staleness; bundling cache now disabled in the render CLI (enableCaching: false)

LOOP 292

No defects.

Would I stop scrolling: yes. The cool dated TYPO3 site scrolling dead → 18f relight into the alive new grid while the camera holds is the strongest beat the system has produced; the site's own '19 Standorte in Wien' pops during the after-chain. Two honest observations: the old site's own green is close to our lime accent, so the Vorher scene is less color-contrasted than the grammar implies (cool grade + muted chip carry the difference); and at 13.4s the clip runs long against the 8-12s archetype target — the before scroll earns its 2.8s, but a tighter 600px scroll is worth trying if Felix wants it snappier.

NOTES

Before source: Wayback 2026-03-12 (last fully-styled TYPO3 capture; snapshots 2026-04-16 and 2026-05-19 rejected half-styled by the §5 integrity gate — screenshots in out/film/).
TYPO3 evidence: markers recorded in before.json checks; day-count intentionally absent from copy (intake line blank).
Plate candidate-05 (curated keep) under the stage; rights recorded in plates.yaml.

client_permissionTRUE

antonio_approvedPENDING

OPEN APPROVAL